Report From The Field: The Defensive Male Writer
There are so many very important articles on the victimization of women in society. And this is not one of them. Nope. This is an altogether different take—this is about when the male writer feels threatened by the empowered female writer. Is it because he does not understand her? Is it because she does not fit his mold of the iconic “writer” model, complete with a tweed jacket and dark-rimmed glasses, and —of course—a penchant for craft beer? It could be one of many reasons, including the simultaneous exoticizing and diminution of women who write.
Being a female and a writer has its interesting twists (I purposely am not saying “woman writer” or “female writer” because we rarely make the distinction “man writer” or “male writer”). Women need to have their voices heard, but they don’t need their voices to be ghettoized into a special bookstore category of “women’s writing.” This suggests that men’s writing is the default and that women’s writing is some sort of sub-category, or—worse—something that happens far off on the exotic island where women write, certainly not on the main continent of male writing.
I am one of the founders and Executive Artistic Director of a literary organization, the Cambridge Writers’ Workshop. We have been leading writing workshops and retreats since 2008, and coincidentally, the founding co-Director and Executive Creative Director, Rita Banerjee, also happens to be female. We are always surprised when, occasionally, people assume that we are a women’s-only organization simply because the directors are women. Something tells me the same would not apply if the directors were male. In fact, we have a balanced ratio of men and women on our executive board and our summer writing retreat in Paris this summer, for instance. Also, there are men as well as women who serve as our faculty members on our retreats. The anthology that several members of the Cambridge Writers’ Workshop are editing, CREDO: An Anthology of Manifestos and Sourcebook for Creative Writing, also has a balanced representation of genders.
When we share about our programs, we mostly get positive responses. However, sometimes we get some strange responses (mainly from male writers) that show a distinctly defensive tone. Could it be that they somehow feel threatened? Their responses never cease to amuse the Cambridge Writers’ Workshop team. Recently, we shared about our writing retreats in Paris and Granada on a community forum. One of the responses was to our Granada Writing Retreat Poster (which prominently features a painting of a female flamenco dancer) from the group moderator (a middle-aged male writer who shall remain un-named). He wrote,
“Yeah, we do Flamenco dancing here all the time. You don’t need to go to Spain.” Later, there was a sardonic joke about how his “more serious” writers’ group would vote on “whether to have a Flamenco dance-off or to drink beer…I believe the beer vote carried the day.”
There are several problems I have with ridiculing a female Flamenco dancer image. Is it the figure of a powerful female dancer, or the Romani (Gypsy) heritage that is being mocked? The commenter assumes that this image cannot be associated with serious writing. What of Lorca and countless other writers who have been inspired by Flamenco and Andalucia? The thing that strikes me is that this same commenter had nothing to say of the iconography of a lighthouse on our Newport retreat poster or the Eiffel Tower on our Paris retreat poster, which was also posted to the forum. But the female Romani Flamenco dancer on our Granada poster…for him, this seemed an easy target! I am going to make a suggestion—one that, I admit, makes an assumption. I am going to assume that he simply could not process the power of this image, and perhaps it even threatened his limited world view. Yes, the body of a beautiful woman of color dancing can exist in a non-sexualized context—in the context of a serious writing workshop, with serious faculty committed to the writing process.
This same commenter completely wrote-off the Cambridge Writers’ Workshop program, citing a desperate comparison that his writing group was not for the likes of us, not “for aspiring writers” but rather “a real-world writer’s workshop now in its tenth consecutive year, moderated by two professional, multi-credentialed, traditionally published authors. I’m one of the moderators…the other is best-selling author, XX. We meet every Monday evening at 7 PM from 10 PM in XX.” I immediately saw that this man, this apparently well-established writer (of low-brow thrillers and graphic novels) was feeling defensive! I thought that perhaps he saw the CWW as a competitor, so I immediately took the higher road and apologized for infringing on his territory, writing “We apologize for the postings. We misunderstood and thought your group was an open platform for the community of writers to post. Just FYI, we are also a professional writers’ workshop that has been meeting regularly for the past eight years and hosting retreats for the past four years, with best-selling faculty members such as David Shields, Kathleen Spivack, and Peter Orner, etc. Please accept our apologies. Now that we understand the nature of your group, we see why posting other opportunities (that may be competition to your model) poses a problem. It won’t happen again! Best regards, Diana Norma and the CWW Team.”
Publically, on the forum, he accepted my apology, but in a private message to me he wrote: “Well…since our workshops focuses on actually producing work rather than retreats, there’s really not that much competition.” More defensiveness covered in seeming nonchalance. Poor man, I thought. Did he not know what a retreat could do for a writer? So many of us writers are holders of day jobs, with family responsibilities. A retreat, as any serious writer would know, can afford the necessary space and time to complete a project and move our writing goals forward. Many of our writers have finished novels, poetry manuscripts, screenplays, and more on our retreats.
Another male writer ridiculed the yoga component to our retreats, asking, “Why yoga? What does it have to do with writing?” He questioned the seriousness of the workshop, but later expressed that he really wasn’t that flexible.
That being said, I want to be clear that I’m not generalizing about the attitude of all male writers. Many are sane and perfectly normal human beings, of course. Some are on our faculty (such as David Shields, Peter Orner, and Steve Aubrey). We recently had one commenter from another writing group out in Portland who said that they wished their writing group had yoga, like ours, saying “That would probably help us a lot.”
If you’re reading this and thinking…hmm…I need a writing retreat myself, we are offering scholarships to serious writers in three categories (Diversity, Student, and Parent) for our Paris (July 22-30) and Granada Writing Retreats (August 3-10). Apply at cww.submittable.com
Diana Norma Szokolyai is a writer/interdisciplinary artist/educator and Executive Artistic Director of Cambridge Writers’ Workshop. Based in Brooklyn, NY, she is author of the poetry collections Parallel Sparrows (honorable mention for Best Poetry Book in the 2014 Paris Book Festival) and Roses in the Snow (first runner-up Best Poetry Book at the 2009 DIY Book Festival). She also records her poetry with musicians and has collaborated with several composers. Her poetry-music collaboration with Flux Without Pause led to their collaboration “Space Mothlight” hitting the Creative Commons Hot 100 list in 2015, and can be found in the curated WFMU Free Music Archive. Szokolyai’s work has been published in Quail Bell Magazine, Lyre Lyre, The Boston Globe, Dr. Hurley’s Snake Oil Cure, and Up the Staircase Quarterly, as well as anthologized in The Highwaymen NYC #2, Other Countries: Contemporary Poets Rewiring History, Always Wondering and Teachers as Writers. Visit her at http://diananorma.com/
*Note: For more about Romani (Gypsy) culture, literature, and the fight for human rights and representation please see VIDA’s “Twenty ‘Gypsy’ Women You Should Be Reading” by Jessica Reidy, which includes Diana Norma Szokolyai.